cardboard package tray speaker holes

The first photo shows original tray with a width of 8 1/2”
Repop photo shows less than 8”

View attachment 1715346922

View attachment 1715346923
Are all of the reproductions made by the same supplier? I did not notice that on the one I installed but I didn't compare them at the time. I see what you mean though . Maybe the tooling for the cut out is used for many other makes and model cars. It is obvious though that the slots look shorter and fatter. Could it be because they are CNC cut verses die stamping of the older trays?