Cracked Valve Guide Pillars - OK to Use?

Thanks for the very competent replies so fast. Many issues bring concern when a little experience can alleviate fears. So the purpose of those pillars was that they were the OE guides, just a hole bored in the raw cast-iron, just like the cylinders. In a "valve job", they bore a larger hole and press in separate tubes as guides, similar to sleeving a cylinder. That leaves the walls of the OE guide thin and easy to break as the new guide is forced in. Seems they don't know that until it cracks and hard to backup at that point, so some shops just leave as is.

Perhaps they could first mill down all the pillars. That appears to be how aluminum heads are cast, without pillars, since they use separate iron guides from the start; but would be more costly and this was a very active shop. I was surprised how inexpensive this valve job had been, ~$90/head, which included repairing a few small cracks.


Those "pillars" are called valve guides. Or you can call them valve guide bosses. Or pillar.

It doesn't hurt anything they say it was done, just shitty work. At this point, I'd make sure all the guides are good and if not, replace them. While they are in there, they SHOULD cut the guides down for a positive seal. I can't imagine a shop today not doing that. Ive been doing it since 1982. No reason EVER to not use a positive seal.