Nitrile gloves, or better alternatives?

Hi all,
I see a lot of people using the nitrile gloves, so I bought a cheap box from wally-world. Not really happy with them, they don't go far enough up my wrist, and it doesn't take much to wear through my index finger.. I don't have a lot of feeling in the end of that finger due to some frostbite somewhere a long the line, so I wind up with a clean hand and a greasy finger tip, lol. I have mechanics gloves, but usually wind up taking them off to start bolts, etc.
Any better options out there other than the wally-world ones?