UCA Bushings don't fit?

That is surely suspect to an issue. Good Arms are easily found to replace them, I had to get one as the UBJ was welded at some point and ripped it apart with a long leverage bar before noticing the weld. No issue with the bushing area but! I suggest making a simple measure across either side to see the difference. Tight is good IMO. You may be able to salvage it but is it worth that? I replaced my welded BJ arm prior to new bushings very cheaply!

I agree that I should've just bought new arms to begin with. I could've bought a new set of control arms with good bushings for what I paid him to put the new bushings and ball joints in. If the control arm does end up being bad, should I try to get at least some of my money back from the guy, I've never really had a mechanic break my parts before. Also, do you know if I can unscrew and reuse the new ball joints that were installed in the control arm? (I did make sure that he knew to thread them, not press them)