Shopping for a comfy soft top 4 seat convertible with a stick. Opinions?

I'm not sure I can agree. But in any event, it's too nice of a car to put through Winter's hell.
My wife daily drives 5.0 Mustangs here in Winnipeg...with good winter tires she never has gotten stuck once and goes to work in the worst weather.
Now I agree that the Bullitt is a bit nice for hard winters... I did drive a 2020 last November it’s a great car for the money...I would say they are my favourite Mustang.