1973+ Duster Taillight Question

I did cut new washers from some closed cell craft foam. But didn't see that sealing well, so added the butyl.

I had an all original 73 Dart Sport, and it had the original bezel gaskets which were made of white foam which is just like polyethylene closed cell foam sheet material that you find being used for packaging material. You can call Detroit Muscle Technologies to see if they carry them precut for the application. Otherwise you can make your own as that material is readily available.

Exactly what I needed. Thank you sir!