To me it looks fine they dont have any noticable wear. But I dont really know what I'm looking at tbh. Its most definitely the bearings tho I compared the two carriers side by side and this one has alot more slop in it. The other carrier once the race is on as barely any movement this one you can wiggle the race around a quarter inch in any direction. I got the cage and bearings off I'm gonna order me a puller and get the bottom part of the bearing off and order new bearings.