need a new chainsaw

-

diymirage

HP@idle > hondaHP@redline
Joined
Oct 12, 2012
Messages
33,764
Reaction score
41,654
Location
michigan
hey guys
i think my cheap chainsaw died on me
not too big a deal, it was a cheapie anyway and i dont use it all that much

i need to replace it, but i dont wont to break the bank and im not a lumberjack (but im allright)

i sit on 2.5 acress and most of the down trees are on the edges, so it needs to be gas or battery (though battery seems like a terrible idea)


any suggestions?
 
A Stihl will last you forever.

I do not recommend Husqvarna. My dad gave me a brand new one. It started right up. Let it sit for about a year, when I actually needed it it only ran for 5 minutes, the cdi box went out. Replaced it with a factory cdi box, it only lasted and hour. Replaced it again with another factory box, it is still running as of the last time I used it.

Most of the time for small stuff trimming tree limbs I have an electric Poulan, I know it will always start, plus its light.
 
I have always had good luck with Stihl or Husqvarna... just keep 'em sharp and wear the gear.
 
Get a Poulan, there cheap and reliable! For what you're doing it will do the job! 65'
 
I have a few Poulans, and 18 yo 14" and a new Poulan pro "pr4218" 18" that I can't kill. Other than maintenance no fuss no muss. Also have a 6 yo Craftsman 20" that has run well, though needed a bit of hi/lo fuel adjustments. None of them will break the bank. I am not a fan of Battery powered saws.

Not a lumberjack but cut a lot of trees on our wooded/forest property (@14 acres). Clean up downed trees after storms, cut and split about 4 face chords per year.

Be well,
Pat
 
Get a Poulan, there cheap and reliable! For what you're doing it will do the job! 65'

that is what i have now, a poulan pro 16 i think
it just doesnt want to stay up on the revs anymore
i put in a new carb last fall and that didnt help
 
that is what i have now, a poulan pro 16 i think
it just doesnt want to stay up on the revs anymore

How old is it? If it's fairly new, there may be a spark arrester screen under the muffler (Thanks California). I had the same issue with a different piece of equipment. I took out that screen because it was plugged up with carbon.
 
couple of years, ill check that next time i head out to the shed


thanks
 
I have two Stihl's chain saws. A model 051 one is from the early 70's starts every time but it's a bear to use. The weight is what kills you. Then a smaller 026 from the mid 80's that still runs like new. I also have back pack blower from the 80's and a hedge trimmer I bought two years ago. Would buy nothing else for small engine equipment
 
Iv had good luck out of Poulan pros I bought my first new chainsaw when I first got out on my own in 2003 It was a poulan pro 18 inch it ran like a champ until last spring I rebuilt the carb and it ran for a little while longer but I couldnt keep it tuned last summer I bought a new poulan pro 18 inch so it lasts from 2003 to 2019 without any problems at all. The only thing I ever done to it was replaced the chain tensioner and the gas cap. For 89 bucks I think that's a pretty good saw lol
 
At one time,I worked for a dealer, with Husky/ Jonsereds as our main lines.
Another time in a rental business, who had a lotta Stihl products.
The Stihls amazed me as to how lightweight they were. In comparison, the Huskys were fat pigs. But I wonder if there was more than a pound between them.
But the Jonsereds were decades ahead in looks,lol.


The thing is when you take them apart, it's like taking a SBM apart; they all look pretty much the same.
I bought a Husky, because that is what I could afford, and it has never let me down. But she's a heavy beast. I used to go out every fall and harvest 10 or 12 cords every September before the snow came. I spent my vacation time doing this. I gotta tell ya, the first two days were murder, until my muscles adapted.
Another thing I can tell you, is that you will never be sorry you bought a lightweight Stihl, they hold their value longer and are easier to sell.And your muscles will thank you for it.
Of these three, I wouldn't be scared to buy any one of them.
_________________________
I got a funny story for ya;
At one time,Stihls had a lot of Magnesium them,at least I think it was that; which I guess is why they are lighter. But Magnesium hates methanol, so be careful to never put any in the gastank.
Back in the early 80s, I was working in a bike shop, and the owner had multiple lines of products, including Jonsereds.... with metal gas tanks, aluminum I thought.
Well, Barney, the owner was involved in 2-wheel racing, even having a local radio celebrity riding his turbocharged Kawasaki racebike. And so it was , that on a Monday, it was my job to get the bike ready for the following weekend. And so his race gas was standing around in unmarked containers, which I had warned against, but I was only 30ish what the heck did I know.
Another one of my jobs was to fix his Japanese motorcycles, along with the lead mechanic who was the resident exotic guru.
And a third duty I had was to make sure the temporary summer helps, whom he hired and had PDI'ing the new stuff were doing a good job.
So this one day, a Jonsered comes to me for shipment up North, could I run it up? Sure boss.
I grab it, check it for gas, pull the rope and it fires right up. I warm it up, give it a workout, twiddle the needles and send it back to the shipping department.
A few days later, older, wiser, business owner, Barney is on my case about this saw.
Yes-sir boss, as soon as it gets back here I'll get on it; in the meantime ship him a new one.
So when it gets back,lol the tank is full of holes. Thru a comedy of errors, the tank had been filled with methanol, which I'm guessing immediately began dissolving the magnesium. When I ran it up, that methanol got inside everything else. And the shipper failed to completely empty the tank. By the time the saw got to it's destination, the methanol was gone, and when I got it, about 4 days from the time of shipping, the thing was not salvageable.
It didn't take long and the boss had new jerry cans for his racebike, of a completely different color, and clearly marked. I never heard a peep about it again, nor a sorry, and I got promoted to working on the exotics; Ducati, Laverda, Moto-Guzy, and other assorted what I called, dinosaurs. Yippee.
I kindof miss that part of my life. Anyway, plastic has pretty much taken over, so I don't think you have this to worry about,lol.
Well Ok I thought it was funny; both then, and, Stihl today,lol.
 
My experience with a Poulan Pro is they are cheap and when they die, they die hard. I had mine for years and suffered with it for at least a couple. Now I have a Craftsman that is brand new, and two months into owning it it acts like the Poulan did at 10 years old. Won't get another one.

One thing I haven't seen anyone mention is bar length. Both my saws have been 20". I couldn't go to anything shorter. Get the longest bar you're comfortable with, it will help you out in the long run for sure.
 
ok, i checked the screen it looks fine

Did you try adjusting the Hi/Lo idle carb settings after you swapped in the new carb? May need a special screw driver to do it. Those adjustment can definitely make a saw run crappy, hard starting, die when revving etc
 
Did you try adjusting the Hi/Lo idle carb settings after you swapped in the new carb? May need a special screw driver to do it. Those adjustment can definitely make a saw run crappy, hard starting, die when revving etc

yes i did, bought the carb that came with the tool, just so i could
 
Husqvarna. I've run a bunch but what I found is when you need the Topend power the Stihl can't match it. With that being said both saws are great machines and would not hesitate to own either but I do have a preference. In the end it all comes down to the blade IMO.....

Be safe in whatever you choose...

JW
 
I bought a Stihl Farm Boss a couple years ago. Love it. Can't stop it.
 
I have a Stihl, a Poulan Pro, along with a Crafrsman, and and old Homelite. They all do a good job.
The reason I'm considering a Kobalt 80 volt, is with my shoulders giving me trouble, I wouldn't have to be jerking on a rope, plus no more often than I use one, I wouldn't have to dump the fuel, and run it empty. If I was still heating with wood, and cutting a couple cord every year, gas all the way.
 
McCulloch 250 LOLOL. Yeh you can tell I'm old. It's still out in the garage, somewhwere

This is not mine, just something I found on the www. Made about the time as my Dart, I think. I bought mine used sometime in the early 70's for "not very much."

 
I have a couple of Echo saws that I inherited from my father. I'm not saying they are the best saws in the world or anything, but I think they are pretty good. I've had very good luck with them and would buy another. My 55 cc Echo saw dates back to 1970, when the company was still called Kioritz Manufacturing, and despite being used hard every year (I cut a lot of wood) it's still on its original piston and cylinder.

What usually kills a gas saw is when the carburetor starts to leak air, and/or the needle valve gets clogged and doesn't pass enough fuel. Either condition will make the saw run lean, depriving the piston and cylinder of sufficient lubrication and causing scoring and seizure. You need to adjust the carb every year to make sure it hasn't leaned out.
 
Get a Stihl MS170. It’s their smallest gas saw, but its awesome. I blew my back out using my big MS391, so I bought the MS170 for limbing and smaller work. Now it’s the only saw I use. It’s a screamer and you just can’t beat it for the money. Poulan’s and Echos’s are just throw away saws in my opinion. The Stihl MS170 is also around $170 which isn’t bad for a high quality saw that will last you for years.
 
-
Back
Top