440/500 Stroker Cam change question

OK, I put the Comp Cam EX295HL-10 hydraulic flat tappet cam in my motor years back. The motor has always be noisy like a solid cam. I had discussions about this in the past but don't want to discuss that right now.
I love the way the car runs. Just a driver /727/323 gear. Did an 11.7 with it at track.
I decided to go solid and picked this Comp Cam CL21-232-4
Now thinking about this, I'm wondering if I should have stayed closer to original specs. I am now looking at Comp. 21-249-4.
I am not an expert at all at this so my question is do you think the car will be worse with the CL21-232-4 or should I purchase the 21-249-4 ?
I'm attaching all three specs. Go easy on me lol.