Run electric fans all the time?

I commented because I have alot of experience with electric fans. I tried to make them work in BB and SB applications. Add A/C and your done
- They are expensive
- At best they dont move enough air
- They tax the **** out your battery/charging system which makes you spend more $ money on expensive electrical components.
- The modern day car bit does not hold water it is not apples to apples in Engineering.
You will never convince myself and many others on this forum that electric fans will out perform a belt driven fan.
Dont get me wrong they have their applications and now and then you may get one to work but over all they are not work the money and effort.

It sounds like you have a lot of experience setting up poorly thought out electric fan systems. If someone put a 500 cfm carb on an 800 hp engine with 5/16 fuel line and a stock mechanical pump would you blame the carburetor for the lack of performance? I bet you wouldn’t.

That’s basically the same thing most people do when they try to switch to an electric fan. They choose an expensive fan rather than one that will move enough CFM for their engine. Then they hook it into the stock wire harness with undersized wires and an underrated alternator. Basically, they guarantee that the fan won’t be able to perform even to its design specs because it won’t pull enough power. And then they control the fan with the cheapest thermostatic switch they can find. And when the car runs hot they blame the fan, just like you’re doing.

I ran a mechanical fan on my Duster before switching to the contour electric fans. The electric fan system on the car now outperforms the mechanical fan it replaced. I daily drive my car in air temperatures that are frequently 100*+, I’ve never had an overheating issue even sitting in stop and go traffic.

And I’m not worried about convincing you or anyone else. The science and the evidence is on my side. Whether or not you accept that doesn’t change a thing. The fact that you say I’ll never convince you, that’s there’s no amount of science or evidence that will get you to accept the facts says more about you than it does anything else. Goldduster318 is right on, the contour system is not that expensive. The stock wiring has to be upgraded on most of these cars anyway. And an upgraded alternator steals far less power than a mechanical fan.

Also have the Contour fan here. The controller was the only expensive part, it was $35 for the fan assy. I don't even use the high speed on the fan ever even at the Woodward Dream Cruise on a high 80's day.

Yes, you can't run a stock charging system. The stock system is pure garbage anyway, long tortured path, undersized wiring, alternators with poor total and at idle output. It should be changed on everyone's car since they basically can't even keep the headlights fully bright at idle with nothing else on. Of course you could upgrade your charging system for about $150 if you know what you are doing and have no more issues.

Cooling systems didn't really change too much but you do need a fan/shroud that fits your radiator. There may be a slight advantage to a crossflow radiator but otherwise it's not terribly different. The air still has to flow through the radiator opening on an A-body. Of course it's also easy to size your radiator wrong or build a thermally inefficient engine.

For example, my uncle has a 2009 Chevy 2500 HD pickup that rolls down the road at almost 23000 lbs on a daily basis towing a skid loader. This truck has electric fans, stays cool, has the A/C blasting, and has 230,000 miles on it. It stays cool no problem.

The mechanical fan is a drag that is costing you HP, fuel mileage, etc, and it's turning when it doesn't need to. Generating 40A to run a bigger electric fan costs about 1hp with efficiency losses from the alternator, worst case 2hp. The mechanical fan is easily 10-30hp depending on what you have. And chances are at RPM the electric fan is off.

Back to the original poster - Sounds like your system works fine. I doubt you gain anything by cooling the temp down below what it runs at with no intervention.

Exactly! 100% right on.