How do hydraulic flat tappet lifters fail?

-
What does the crank surface look like?
Okay, it looks a lot worse than I remember. Regardless, the journals are going to be polished.

D7CDED25-670E-4E06-ACC9-DBA79A497417.jpeg
 
Just went thru similar ordeal on a newly purchased Dodge 886
Low miles under 40 thousand engine popped as u throttled it up
Well after removing intake found a wipped out cam lobe so being truck is very heavy I ordered an Isky towing cam and luckily all went well
I soaked lifters used Isky lube with cam and dumped a bottle of stp over cam before putting intake on
I guess THIS TIME luck was on my side about 500 miles on said cam and zero issues also purchased Summit brand lifters from a member .

20201018_164626.jpg


20200821_161005.jpg
 
I believe the journals will need to be polished. (In fact, I'm going to have them polished regardless.) I'll post some pics in a bit, but I can just barely see some very light scoring on the surface. I can feel grooves just a couple thousandths deep with my fingernail.


Just a quick squirt o' WD40 and called it good...why do you ask?

I'm kidding. I used the Sta Lube moly assembly lube. On the bearings, I smeared maybe a 1/32" or 1/16" layer with a gloved hand, but I knew a lot would squeeze out. For my education, can I ask what indicators you're seeing that make it look oil starved?

The shiny area in the middle seems to indicate a very thin oil film......
 
Just went thru similar ordeal on a newly purchased Dodge 886
Low miles under 40 thousand engine popped as u throttled it up
Well after removing intake found a wipped out cam lobe so being truck is very heavy I ordered an Isky towing cam and luckily all went well
I soaked lifters used Isky lube with cam and dumped a bottle of stp over cam before putting intake on
I guess THIS TIME luck was on my side about 500 miles on said cam and zero issues also purchased Summit brand lifters from a member .

View attachment 1715617312

View attachment 1715617313
Wow, sorry that happened to you. I guess it's been said before in this thread, it doesn't really matter why it happened at this point - we just know it happened and now it's time to fix it.
 
Okay, I didn’t doubt anyone who said I needed to pull the engine apart, but since I did, here’s some proof I found that says it was indeed necessary. This is the #4 main bearing, and you can see a fine silt of cam and lifter material that has made its way throughout the engine. That **** is EVERYWHERE.
783C19ED-A646-49A9-8DEA-B1C3C2A57515.jpeg


I’m confident that if I didn’t break everything down to get it clean, I’d be sealing my fate for either another failure right away, or at the very least, premature death to the engine.

The crank is at the machine shop being cleaned and polished, in the meantime I’ll be cleaning the block and prepping for reassembly.
 
It’s refreshing to see someone taking the time to repair things correctly. Well done. It will reward you in the future.
 
Not just in the circled areas of your bearing photo, I see a lot of evidence of trash moving through that entire bearing.
 
It’s refreshing to see someone taking the time to repair things correctly. Well done. It will reward you in the future.
Thanks. The way I see it, why ask for advice if you’re not going to follow it?

I’m also trying to see the silver lining here, since I’ve been wanting to paint the water pump and clean up some other things. I also found the source of my exhaust leaks in the process, so I think it was a good decision all around to pull the motor.
 
Thanks. The way I see it, why ask for advice if you’re not going to follow it?

I’m also trying to see the silver lining here, since I’ve been wanting to paint the water pump and clean up some other things. I also found the source of my exhaust leaks in the process, so I think it was a good decision all around to pull the motor.
The silver lining is you're smart enough to fix it right this time and not do it over again down the road lol
 
-
Back
Top