Did you use the correct size PAL nut? There is #10 and 1/4" (plus #6 and #8 but I've never encountered those on my car, yet). I've broken new stuff and it sucks.
All my original GTS badges including the door emblems had the studs broken off. I have 3 re-pops because I have a stripe delete car and none of them broke. Not saying any one is better than the other but **** happens and they were just pot metal to begin with. I fixed my interior ones by epoxying flat head screws in place of the studs. Hopefully Classic makes good one it. Plan on their response taking time, that is what I encounter when I had an issue with one of their products.
