Online selling etiquette

If guy one or two wants to cherry pick what you have and guy three isn't interested after the tree is trimmed... well you get the picture.

Call guy three on his offer, have him F&F paypal to you and let him come pick it up. If he balks even the slightest, move on. Never take payment via good and services in paypal for a local pick up... you WILL get burned.

Give 1 and 2 a shot after that.

Or tell guy 1 you have someone that wants it all, if he also wants it all he's welcome to come get it, no partial purchase. Move down the line.