P245/60R15 tires. Which would you choose?

I am unfamiliar with the Milestar Streetsteel tires, but the other 3 are good drivers with good dry weather grip. I like the Coopers a little better than the BFG’s, which are fine but the Coopers are better in the rain. Just drive sane. Like a cautious adult and you’ll be fine.

I myself would move to a 8 inch wide wheel for the 245’s.