Full manual valve body, yea or nay?

I agree with his recommendation. I would also suggest something better than OEM bands & clutches. It will likely hit hard and quality aftermarket stuff would be more durable.

I ran one in the street in my first car, a 340 Challenger. Under the right conditions, it surprised a lot of people when I was able to chirp the tires on the 1-2 shift, even at low rpm's. But the shifting got to be bothersome after a while. If I hadn't gone to race-only, I probably would have gotten the best shifting valve body that retained the auto feature.
I agree. I tried the MVB years ago and it got to be really annoying, so went back to plain jane valve body with a good shift kit. Manual 1-2 valve is there so I can pull it into 1st at higher speeds if needed, but the ability to concentrate on driving instead of what gear it is in means a lot to me.