That was a big fat fail

You said you can see where they are jumping the fence. Fixing that spot will just make them find another spot to jump over.
However, leave the fence alone, put a few no trespassing signs and simply forget that you left a half sheet of plywood with a couple dozen nails or screws run thru it, pointy side up, laying out there where they land. They'll only jump the fence once. Word will get out.
Ewww... sadistic I like it...:)