Sudden Power Loss (opinions)

they are 225/55/15's and it is a suregrip rear end.

Ok well then 225/55-15s math to 24.7; and so the size-difference might be a wash.
And as for the sure grip, if it is the cone type, then after all these years, it may not be working anymore, and it only has 2 spiders. So that story is still plausible.