Repair or replace this fender (AMD)

To all the body repairmen out there. In a few weeks I'll be turning my car over to the body shop. I have this fender issue.

Will it be cheaper for me to hand the car to him with a new AMD fender ($898 after shipping & before tax) or let them straighten it out (labor)?

My gut is it is at least a full day's labor so it may be close to equivalent?

6.jpeg

image-01-01-22-01-42-2.jpeg

image.jpg

image.jpg

image.jpg