Repair or replace this fender (AMD)

"Rosette fasteners" are the rivets used to attach the vin tag to the dash. Screws attached the fender tag.
It would depend on the year. '66-7 also used rosettes attaching the VIN to the driver's side door pillar. '65 and earlier, they were psuedo spot welded on the door pillar. I've also run across a few oddball '68 models with riveted-on fender tags that look to be factory. They have completely different code numbers on them too. The rivets were not rosette's however, just a regular type rivet.