Repair or replace this fender (AMD)

The fender can be fixed but, unless your taking it to somebody who cares or not is going to depend on the type of repair you get. If your going to your local jokal body shop they sure as hell aren't drilling out spot welds and separating the headlight section from the fender then welding it back it. A restoration shop or, a guy who does his own work would care enough to do that kind of work to make the repair. Your local jokal body shop will pull it the best they can and throw filler at it and, paint to match...ish.