Starter splash shield

Got a new “authentic” reproduction shield for my ‘69 Cuda restoration that was labelled as fitting 67-72 A bodies - NOT!!
The original shield at the top of the photo is from my son’s ‘69 Cuda and the bottom is the repro. Does anyone have an original style shield in restorable condition?
Thx
Jim
D9D3EBB1-B537-425C-BD45-175F8E856762.jpeg F1D89641-427E-44B8-B155-96BACB26FBCA.jpeg