Clutch fan vs derale single 2400cfm fan

It depends on your application, I have a derale unit, it worked fine and pushed a lot of air (2400cfm), but then it died after 2 years of use aprox. It did not last as expected. I bought the replacement fan and it works fine now, but not sure it it will last longer. A few years ago I changed my Rangers mechanical fan for a universal electric one from summit (dont remember the brand) and never had a problem in 10 years I owned the vehicle.

for intake I have a hood intake sealed from the engine compartment, works perfect.