Going to a Mopar Gold Mine...

Yea no fender tag, but he has original title. So what is a good price for that as a roller?
A good price for one guy is obscene to another... so the question becomes what is a good price for YOU? Sorry that's not much help, but you are the one that needs to be comfortable with the purchase. If it's not enough for him, move on; and console yourself by thinking fondly of all the money you saved not having to source a million E body parts $$.