Slant Six 170 vs. 225

yes, it definitely does matter. anything bigger than the actual outlet diameter of the manifold flange doesn't help flow a bit. the 1-3/4 to 1-7/8" hole in the manifold flange is a bottleneck!!!! It doesn't take much with a die grinder and burr, to open the manifold opening. Don't worry, there's lots of meat there// you won't be "too thin" but it DOES make a difference!!!!
Rusty Rat Rod had a thread with pix about this very thing, about a year ago right here........
and the last one I did that treatment to, as cast, the exhaust opening was way off center, compared to a flange gasket bolted up loosely as a guide// so that gives you a chance to "square things up" at the same time. (most of the flange gaskets I have found with that bolt spacing are a 2-1/4" hole, so that's as far as I grind)

Really, do you have a dyno split from before and after the modification? How about a time slip from the track? Do you have anything other then Rusty's butt-o-meter, that shows he thought there was an improvement?

A 2 /12" exhaust pipe bolted directly to the exhaust manifold on my wife's Duster was worth 2 tenths on the 1/8th track that we raced at.