340 Engine Shake

I think you’re getting a little ahead of yourself. Your engine is not junk, and as of right now you should still be considering a refresh IMO. Every cast iron engine on earth has rust flakes in the water jackets, that’s not uncommon at all. Let your machinist have a look, make a plan and follow it. If he says it’s junk then move on to your 5.9.

You're right. My wife had to talk me down as well. I'll keep everyone updated on what the outcome is.