Main cap girdles re-discussed

I was just rereading a thread I commented on a long while ago about main cap girdles and the ending consensus was a no..... HOWEVER I did read it and it seemed to me that everyone was only implying it to 2 bolt main girdles on an LA factory block. Now I do understand that some people still run 4 bolt caps and leave the outer bolts unused just to help transfer the stress across a more broad surface area. So my question is what does everyone think about running 4 bolt caps for that and adding a girdle on top? Yay? Nay? Why?