Wheel Brands (Specialty Wheel or Wheel Vintiques)

It seems like you are asking them to produce a different width of beauty ring for every different wheel offset they offer. Or at least, that's what it seems like it would take. No?

If they are just reproducing the factory beauty rings exactly, you would expect them to fit a 5.5" wide wheel, but that's it.

As for Mike's observation, that is kind of what happens when you put a much wider rim on the same center — you get this deep crevice. Again, it would require a new design of beauty ring, not just a reproduction of the factory style. The wheel makers would have to decide if all this customization would be financially worthwhile.