Where do I look now

Woah. That’s nice and all but it’s about as relevant as the price of tea in China. Your system doesn’t take into account condition/shape and even more imprtantly, available funds! If you only have $5k, even a 20 point car will be out of budget. And that will lead to another thread like this being created.

Your method looks a lot like the swordsman‘s method here:

Just add in points for paint and rust
It's just a guideline