DOES THE HDK SUSPENSION K-MEMBER HANDLE BETTER THAN A T-BAR SUSPENSION?

I'd argue that these lack the long term durability of a stock based torsion bar system but nobody I know drives these cars 30,000 miles a year on bad roads so that may be a moot point.
I do see a difference in the K members that appears like it favors the stock system in terms of stiffness and durability.
The aftermarket stuff does look nice. It weighs less. If steering response is better, I can appreciate that but the Borgeson units I've installed don't have that center slop that even a fresh rebuilt Firm Feel unit has.
In short, the OP seems to have come closest to an even playing field for comparison of stock based versus aftermarket. For that, you have my respect and thanks.

It would be interesting to see some FEA on these systems. Looking at pics online I like the HDK setup the most since it uses a strut rod for the LCA like factory and the K-member looks beefier with more triangulation than QA1 or RMS and uses square instead of round-profile tubing. I doubt many guys are running from the cops through dry creek beds with COC front ends though lol.

Even though my preference is with torsion bars, if I had a Mopar with COC front suspension already it would be stupid to convert back. I don't think anyone in their right mind would do that.

For reference, I have a 1970 Plymouth Duster that I use for cruising and autocross. I’ve only been autocrossing for a 3.5 years and have approximately 175 autocross runs on the car. I’ve never driven anything else on an autocross course, only this car. Until the summer of 2023, the car was setup with a stock style torsion bar suspension with parts designed specifically for improved handing. My t-bar setup consisted of the following parts.

  • Sway a way 1.08 bars
  • Hotchkis front and rear sway bar, non-adjustable shocks, and leaf springs
  • SPC gen 1 upper control arms
  • FMJ Spindles
  • Aluminum tie rod sleeves
  • QA1 adjustable strut rods
  • Fully welded biscuit type K-member and LCAs
  • Borgeson steering box
  • 14” front discs and 12” rear discs
  • Falken Azenis 200TW 235/40-18 front tires, 275/35-18 rear tires
  • Alignment- 6.25 degrees caster, 1.5 degrees camber
This combination of parts resulted in a very good handling car. Unlike drag racing where the car with the most HP usually has the fastest car, the same doesn’t hold true on the autocross. Having a properly set up car is probably 75% of the equation. Driver skill is the last piece of the puzzle and is the hardest to make up. There is no replacement for seat time! I’ve never won a big event, nor am I the fastest at any given event. If I were to describe my skill, I’d say I am slightly better than mediocre. My car is always the oldest at my local events and I’m typically within the top 25% of the cars there. Most of which are modern compact cars.

My TB setup is similar to yours but with 1.14" Sway-a-way bars (quite stiff but not as harsh as some newer cars). I have the same tie rod sleeves and adjustable strut rods as you but the stock K-member is not welded (some day). Hellwig sway bars from @BergmanAutoCraft and Hotchkis leaf springs. Steering box is a Firm Feel Stage 2 PS box with minimal on-center play, maybe 1/8-turn at most. 12" OE Mopar-style front discs from Dr. Diff and stock 10" rear drums. Alignment specs are very close to yours but I got the caster with 'band-aid' offset UCA bushings, really want some SPC uppers and tall ball joint. The biggest deficiency is I'm running stock-replacement Sachs shocks which are far too soft for the spring rates, I think my next upgrade will be the Fox Monotube adjustable shocks from Peter. My tires aren't as grippy, Continental ExtremeContact DWS-06 all-seasons but I am running 255-wides in the front as opposed to 235s.

I was hoping to make it to an open lapping/HPDE event at a road course near me this year but with a wedding and honeymoon being planned I might not have the money lol. I'd try an auto-x event but with these soft shocks the stability in rapid direction changes kinda sucks. Hopefully in 2025 I'll be putting down the cash for shocks, UCAs and a DIY alignment setup and hitting the track as much as possible. Road Atlanta is on my bucket list.