Old OEM Dash Pad finish?

I have an old dash pad for my Barracuda I am going to use, and after a warm water and brush treatment, it looks nice but obviously needs some shine to it.
But... it´s a race car, not a car show Hot Rod, so I don´t want it too sparkling shiny. Just nice 50 years ago shiny.
What do I use? Some sort Spray Can I suppose?
Thanks.
OEM dash pad.jpg