Builders: Square engine, Over Square, or Under Square for you?

People generally go out of their way to run longer rods if they can, what situation would you go shorter as the primary goal ? Not for some secondary reason like to be able to run shorter deck and or stroker crank etc..
A street engine. This is where people spend too much time with their noses in hot rod books and buying all the forum gurus BS. A short rod is good for high piston speed and it makes the engine pull more vacuum at low RPM. Generally speaking, that's what you want in a street engine. This is another case of "everybody's doin it, so it must be the thing to do". As I said before, long rods have pros and cons, just as short rods. It boils down to WHAT you're doing. Read this:
https://www.enginebuildermag.com/2016/08/understanding-rod-ratios/