The ABS headliner is a better product, and it will last forever. They do take a little bit of fitting, but what doesn’t?
I would recommend getting the uncovered version, it makes it easier to trim to fit and the vinyl covered ones don’t use a very good glue, or at least they didn’t used to. I bought one that was already covered with the foam backed vinyl and it delaminated in the heat. I just resprayed it with adhesive but if you’re gonna do that you can do the whole thing yourself. Plus being uncovered makes it easier to trim to fit. You can leave them uncovered, cover it yourself or have an upholstery shop cover it.
And unlike the fabric ones the ABS or cardboard headliners can be installed with the glass in.
1974 PLYMOUTH DUSTER 5.2L 318cid V8 Headliner | Shop Now at RockAuto