Hurt the 904 and 8.75 at the same time

No lock at all. It's totally smooth both directions. I can spin it either direction and it'll keep rotating like a top.

So it's had this loud thwack sound while idling for quite some time, you're telling me that was sprag rollers knocking around in the converter?
If it's been quite some time, the damage to the fins would've happened a while ago,....I DO know that I happened on an older SuperHoleshot B&M, & when I checked it out, I couldn't hear much of anything wrong until I really drained the fluid out as completely as I could, then I could shake it & it sounded like a big metal Maraca.