Tire shop over torqued lug nuts (1969 Dart). Should I redo it?

You change passenger car and pick up tires with hand tools? Wow...I am impressed :thumbsup:
Yes. In fact, I won the Georgia state tire rodeo 3 years in a row when I was a 20 something kid. With an old Coats 30-30 with passenger car tires and with hand tools on 7.50-16 lock rings. We didn't air them up due to liability. I don't remember my quickest time, but it was under a minute for hand changing.