When good is not enough, Camshaft time again.

I think getting Comp involved would throw a wrench in the whole works. What I would do would be to mic the journals of the cam that came out and have the new cam's journals machined to match. In fact, if it was mine, it'd already be back together and running.
I assumed the new cam was a comp... Lack of quality control.

Sch.....r instructed me to mic all the lobes for taper, when they're coming out of that vendor.