1968 Dart cooling system & gauge Questions

Depending on the cap type you want check for the valve hanging down. The numbers below were just the caps I had from my adventure in radiator caps and both were manufactured by MOTORAD, look identical and have no numbers stamped on them except the 16 lbs


This one will build pressure from the beginning of the heating of the cooling system (note the valve is closed)
(Carquest Premium Radiator Cap: 16 PSI 10231)
View attachment 1716545107

This one will only pressurize after some spot boiling occurs (Note the valve is open, factory style)
Murray 16 psi Radiator Cap - 7616
View attachment 1716545106
My cap would appear to be the one on the top. That was the only cap they showed for my car other than a Stant LeverLock style which they didnt have. We dont even have CarQuest out here anymore.
So which of these two styles is "better" in your opinion?