17" x 7" Magnum, Charger, 300 Steel Rims

Yea, I borrowed a rim off my friends 300 and bolted it up to my new Yukon axle's and when tightening the bolts up I noticed the wheel nuts were binding a bit. I removed the rim and then I had a cracked stud as it tried to pull it over to the side.
I think I went to tire rack and looked up rims for the 300 and noticed that the pattern was different. I also noticed that this is the Mercedes Benz pattern.

Your Yukon is 5x5. (if it's 5-lug)

No wonder it messed up your stud.
You can run a 5x115 wheel on a 5x114.3 bolt pattern no problem.

The mercedes bolt pattern is 5x112.
Won't work on a 5x114.3 or 5x115.

I work for MHT wheels (Foose, Dub, Jesse James, etc.) as a wheel designer.
There really isn't a problem with running the 5x115 wheels on a 5x114.3 bolt pattern if they are hubcentric.