has anybody used sherman and associates

it is pretty well established that all repop sheet metal comes from the same factory. where the difference comes in is shipping costs. i needed a fender for my Warlock, online i found one for $65, but shipping was $108. Sherman wanted $130 for the fender, but they are local and deliver to my favorite local junkyard as part of their normal route. and junkyard hooked me up with their discount, $30 off. which fender did i buy? always beware of shipping costs!