No doubt that's one ugly jersey but there's competition for ugliest of all time. The Habs retro jailbird uniforms are hideous, the Bruins mustard color one with a bear head in the middle, the Islanders fisherman one to name a few :bootysha:
I think you nailed the problem right there, no western team player has won it, that's pretty typical and will no doubt work against Hank. It should really be between Hank, Brzgalov and Miller. Crosby and Ovechkin have a great supporting cast so I don't think either of them should get it. As much as I want Hank to win it I think Miller will and he too deserves it.