Odd Comment in Mopar Action..

I believe the Ford 9 inch uses tapered axle bearings. As for Chevys, they use roller bearings with c-clips. Have you ever seen a GM product on the side of the road with a wheel, drum and axle assembly not too far from it? That's because the c-clip broke under an axial (sideways) load. The c-clips are all that hold the axles in under cornering. Heavy equipment, trucks, etc. use tapered bearings almost exclusively. Most have "floating" axles where each axle has two tapered bearings in opposite directions for maximum load carrying, both radial and axial.

Now I agree that Ehrenberg is closed minded and opinionated (among other things,) but he knows his stuff. He also knows a lot of engineers at Chrysler and elsewhere, which is where he gets his info from.

Just because you, I or anyone else has not seen a failure doesn't mean it can't happen. If a failure (especially a catastrophic one) can be avoided why take a chance, even though the solution may not be a convenient one? I think most would agree: I wouldn't want the first failure to be on my car.

Fact: Ball bearings (such as the "green" bearings) cannot take a lot of axial load. Roller bearings cannot take any. Period! Why do you think the front wheel bearings are tapered? Most of the time ball bearings would be OK at the drags or on the street, but if you're gonna do any autocross or road racing a la Green Brick, you need tapered bearings to take the axial loads. I'm not gonna trust the "green" bearings under agressive street driving either.

I wouldn't put "green" bearings or F-body spindles on my car.
I agree with almost everything Mr.Ed says. Tappered roller bearings are a superior design. Just about all cars came with ball bearing front wheel bearings back in the 50's but they wouldn't hold up as well as tappered roller bearings so the ball bearings went bye bye. Will ball bearings work? Sure....but for how long? I've pulled 40+year old Mopar rear axle shafts out with original bearings that were still good. When I had my repair shop it was very rare to have to change one. Usually it was because someone screwed up the endplay on a 3rd member swap. Now 7 1/4's, Ford 7", 8", and 9" were a different story. We replaced lots of those.....all ball bearing design. GM? please....running the bearing right on the axle shaft....yeah that was a great idea. All you have to do is look at what heavy duty applications use. 3/4 ton and up trucks (the good old ones anyway) all had tappered roller bearings in the rear. The newer models that don't, are the ones that have problems. Are most green bearings good quality? Sure.....and they'll last many years before you need to replace them under normal circumstances. Are they a better design than the A7 tappered roller bearing? Not a chance.
Thanks, Mark