Finally got the well liner from legendary. It took 1 and a half months vs less than a week from Classic Ind.
Took it out of the bag and compared it to the one I purchased from Classic Ind.
First the part numbers.
Classic Ind. (Sorry for the sideways image)
Legendary (top line)
A side by side of the plastic snap strap and vinyl
Legendary at top, Classic at bottom.
Notice the Classic plastic is white like my OEM. (OEM might have turned white over 52 years?)
Both fabrics look the same on both sides and closely match OEM. The stitching on the classic one is a little neater in some spots but the legendary has some better seams
The legendary plastic has rounded slots that will wear better, and is more like the OEM.
The Classic one has square cut holes which I suspect will start to split over time. Also note the slit to the right of the slot at the stitch line. It is at every snap and again I suspect will lead to failure.
Backside (trunk) legendary is on top
A lot of the stitching is the same, oddly some of the seams on the legendary are better than the Classic and visa-versa.
The cut of both look like they came from the same template and both are the same size.
Neither are the same as OEM in some areas like the part that goes between the seat and chrome strip.
Legendary on top.
The cut at the ends is different from each other, unfortunately my OEM ends are gone.
In the end I'm going with the legendary.
My reasoning is the plastic strip. The rounded slots should last longer.
Nothing else was significantly better one to the other.
Took it out of the bag and compared it to the one I purchased from Classic Ind.
First the part numbers.
Classic Ind. (Sorry for the sideways image)
Legendary (top line)
A side by side of the plastic snap strap and vinyl
Legendary at top, Classic at bottom.
Notice the Classic plastic is white like my OEM. (OEM might have turned white over 52 years?)
Both fabrics look the same on both sides and closely match OEM. The stitching on the classic one is a little neater in some spots but the legendary has some better seams
The legendary plastic has rounded slots that will wear better, and is more like the OEM.
The Classic one has square cut holes which I suspect will start to split over time. Also note the slit to the right of the slot at the stitch line. It is at every snap and again I suspect will lead to failure.
Backside (trunk) legendary is on top
A lot of the stitching is the same, oddly some of the seams on the legendary are better than the Classic and visa-versa.
The cut of both look like they came from the same template and both are the same size.
Neither are the same as OEM in some areas like the part that goes between the seat and chrome strip.
Legendary on top.
The cut at the ends is different from each other, unfortunately my OEM ends are gone.
In the end I'm going with the legendary.
My reasoning is the plastic strip. The rounded slots should last longer.
Nothing else was significantly better one to the other.
