I'm going thru a similar hassle with a 70 Duster I bought with a clean Fl. title in the mans name I bought it from. I take it to Tag office to transfer the title. No the woman says. It was purchased from a guy in NY. Before 1973, NY was a non title state. The guy I bought it from had a NY tag registration and Bill of sale. He was issued a Fl tittle to the car on 6/2018. But apparently the guy in NY re registered the car in 7/2018 which makes it the most legal document! I and the guy I bought it from have been fighting to get it fixed for 2 months. NY needs to take it out of their system before they can issue me a title!