ATF+4 41TE Trans..

-

OneOfMany

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
3,757
Reaction score
181
Location
Winnipeg, MB
I am looking for a "definitive" answer on the suitability of using a Dexron III ATF with a "friction modifier" as being a suitable, warrantable replacement for ATF +4.

Too make a long story short. I own a 98 3.8L Caravan with the 604/41TE transaxle. My only concern from day one has been the plethora of tranny failure stories associated with this trans. After much research, I came to the realization that the vast majority of failures were due to the use of Dexron ATF. I have always used ATF+4 in the trans, and so far, no issues.

Now, yesterday my wife decided to take my van in for an oil change and like all of these quickie marts, they topped up my tranny with Dex. How much? I dont know. I called them, and they responded that Dex is fine. I said it is not fine, and so up the chain I went. Finally, one area manager after listening to my concerns, agreed that my van should have ATF+3 (no longer avail.) or ATF+4. Since they dont use an "approved" ATF+4, they use an additive to "bring it up to spec". I had them fax me the info on the additive - Shift-Rite Platinum made by a company called Run-Rite. I contacted Run-Rite and asked them if the product is "certified" (as all ATF+ must be). After the basic blah, blah, I told them to fax me proof of such. Of course, they faxed me their "independent" tests on how great their product is (in a GM 700R4 yet). I called back, and supposedly someone will be contacting me lol.

I am wondering if anyone has a "definitive" answer on whether this or other so-called friction modifiers are accepted by Chrysler.

Please don't link me to the billion websites that individuals state yes (Amsoil) or No. I have been to hundreds of these pages, and NONE states Chrysler's position, and according to their certification process, no additives are listed at this time.

Thx
Grant
 
All I can tell you is I did a flush & filter on my 89 Dakota and refilled with Dextron III. I got so much shudder in the torque converter lock up during the test drive I turned around drove home flushed out the Dextron and filled with ATF +3 (no +4 at that time). The shudder immediately went away. Up to that point I had topped off with Dextron III with no issues and the owners manual even said it was OK. But for sure the tranny didn't like a full swap over of the fluid.

There has been a number of TSBs recommending ATF+4 over even +3 so IMHO I would take it some where where they can flush out the Dextron and replace with ATF +4. And I don't think you will find any data that says Dextron with an additive meets Chrysler warranty requirements.

I believe your owners manual recomends only ATF +3 or +4 so you should have a good case in small claims court to get the quick change shop to refund the cost of the their work.
 
My shop uses the mod. and I've never seen any problems with it..... However I will only use actual +4 in my trans.
If the shop is corp. owned talk with the store manager tell him your concernes and express that you only want the correct fluid in your trans... no modifiers. If he won't correct the situation just follow the corp. ladder and i'm sure the Dist. manager will make it right. In my shop I would rather just make the customer happy and move on, If I don't i'll just end up looking like an *** and the DM will have me make the customer happy anyway.
Where did you go anyway?
 
-
Back
Top