I guess as long as it does not negatively effect the door panel backing it could work fine. What about a good seal to the door frame? The plastic sheeting if done correctly is sealed tightly to the frame short of the desired openings for the handle etc.
I used the original plastic and dum/dum approach in the back as it conforms to the body and feel it is the best seal.
Oddly the front is only spray tacked around the door frame. Both are taped with with a paper type black masking tape and the bottom edge of the plastic is folded up to the inside.
View attachment 1715240429
View attachment 1715240439