Sorry I'm late to the thread. I am the guy that "whined" about a rearend I bought and couldn't get apart. I just got back this morning from a 3,100 mile trip to help a fellow FABO member out with transporting his Dart for little more than fuel money. I spent my 3 day weekend and drove hard for the Mopar community.
As you can see in the video
@RustyRatRod posted and pics in my thread I tried every way I could (at home) to get an axle out of a very misrepresented 8 3/4. The only thing I didn't do was take it to a shop. I did consult a rearend shop and got guidance but nothing worked.
Backstory: I was at a swap and was very busy running my booth. A neighboring booth had the rear. The booth was operated by members of the club that puts on the biggest Mopar only swap and show west of the Mississippi and I trusted them. The fella that owned the rear and myself talked in passing and he vouched that it was a very good rebuildable core. We agreed to leave it at their booth until it was time to pack up for the day. When I got it home I pulled one axle and you would think this thing was at the bottom of the ocean. I couldn't get the other side off but it was obvious that this rear was opened up to the elements for a very long time. The outside looked great but there was evidence of rats living inside the rearend (leaves, sticks, and rat ****). I messaged the seller and he did admit that he knew no history on the rearend and that he only got it from an aquaintence and that it was sitting outside, missing an axle. He had put an axle in it with plans to sell it. I told him that I tried heat, slide hammer, chain and block, filling it up with WD40,... and he deflected with insults to my abilities and automotive accumen. I started a thread and
then he immediately wanted to give me part of my money and
demanded that I not say anything about the mess. Nope. FU Troy Bray.
In the end, his ego is just way too big for him to admit that he should have disclosed that the rearend was open to the elements for years and to be a helpful Mopar brother from the beginning. I'll put it this way. He didn't
WANT to give me money back and he resisted for a long time. He only offered me money to shut up and not bring up his name. If it were me or any other of the good members on here we would have apologized and offered a refund based on caring and not to hide something. This guy never felt bad about hiding the fact that he sold a rat **** rearend.
I tried everything and pulling on the axle, chained to a tree, with 2500 Ram in 4 low was the last straw. I ended up having to cut the housing apart to salvage a total of : one backing plate, a third member case, and the one axle that did come out. Gears pitted with rust, housing cut to peices, one axle cut at the splines to get the third member out, ....
Some here viewed me as whining. Some said I should be happy I got money back on the deal. I got money back but I would have rather not went through the whole deal. If I would have known about the rear sitting in the high desert exposed to the elements I may have still bought it but not complained when I discovered it was junk. I may have not bought it. But, I was told it was a good core and the seller ended up being one of the biggest jerks I have ever come across in the Mopar world and this guy is supposedly a Mopar guru that works with big names and builds high profile Mopars. The lesson is that some of the biggest names in a given industry can be some of its biggest jerks.