I have a 64 Dart, 3.91 gears and 2.35 15s I used this gear for me.
391 speedo gear 2538940 25.6 tire 20 40 ORANGE 52068062 20
I think you are in between sizes, but this should be very close for you?
Cope racing has a chart, if you can not find it call John at cope transmissions. He will tell you.. And has the gears too!