Valiant dilemma - long post

-

rmchrgr

Skate And Destroy
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
4,361
Reaction score
1,862
Location
Stamford, CT
Having a dilemma regarding whether or not to keep my Valiant. I've been gearing up to sell it these last few months. There are a few reasons for this which I'll attempt to explain below. Thanks in advance for reading.

It's a well-known fact that early A's don't get a lot of love on the open market and there ain't much in the way of parts for these cars. It's not entirely bleak but nothing like what's out there for Chargers, Road Runners etc. I didn't buy it as an investment but the deeper you get into it, the harder it will be to recoup your costs if you decide to sell down the road.

They're also limited in two key areas, namely room in the engine compartment and rear wheel wells. Now I know there's ways around this stuff, but not without some effort. I'm running 245's on the rear and they just clear, anything larger would require moving the springs in one way or another. Headers are proven to work, but it seems like a nightmare to try to get them in, fenderwell or otherwise. To me, the effort could be better spent working on things that don't need as much massaging or expense just to get things to fit. Other cars are just easier to work with in these particular areas.

And really what I'm after is a '70-'72 Duster. I'm a Duster fan, I want one and have for a long time. There's much more out there in the way of parts and there's more room to work with on a '70s A body than an early A. Plus they're just cool when they're done right.

Here's the rub though. My wife and I have a little history with the car. I won it off Ebay back in the early summer of 2005. We are the second owners. We met the 90-year-old lady who's car it was for 40 years. We flew out to rural Indiana to pick it up and drove it back to Brooklyn. We took it on a baseball stadium tour later that summer and basically just enjoyed driving it around. There's a sentimental attachment there and it definitely would be sad to see it go down the road. I still had my '65 Belvedere project at that point, so I really wasn't thinking about hot rodding the Valiant. I figured it would need paint at some point but I never got to it with my other project still going.

I actually formulated a cool plan for it. I was going to make it into an econo driver - keep the Slant and hop it up with all the usual stuff and put an 833OD behind it for some real fun. I got the trans and related parts already. I would rebuild the undercarriage for safety, (disk brakes, etc.) which I did earlier this year. Drives great now and stops much better than it used to. Never rebuilt the Slant or put the trans in, it's all sitting in my attic.

The story took a little turn when I sold the Belvedere project back in February. Now the only Mopar I had left was the Valiant so I started eying it for modification. I hatched a new plan that included a small block stroker - definitely a bad-*** little street machine. Cool in anyone's book but something in me says I'd rather it be a Duster.

Also, the Valiant would require paint. It's a very solid car by all accounts, with the only rust I can see in two small spots - one in the lower driver's-side quarter and one on the top of the driver's fender. The fender could easily be replaced or repaired and patch panels are available for the quarter. The trunk and frame are in excellent shape. Painting this thing right would require taking it apart though, which is something I'd rather not get involved with again. My last project stalled at this point and I ended up selling the car because of it. Restoration requires a huge investment in time. I have some, but I'd rather be burning rubber instead of painting under-dash bracketry.

I'd probably be willing to pay a bit more for a car I didn't have to restore, though finding something like that can be difficult. Not impossible though.

So what to do - stick it out with the Valiant or sell it, take what I can get for it and find a Duster that doesn't need too much to make it presentable and build my machine from that starting point.

Thanks for the input!

Greg
 

Couple of points:

"And really what I'm after is a '70-'72 Duster. I'm a Duster fan, I want one and have for a long time."

Obviously you want a Duster. It sounds like the Valiant is a safe driver/cruiser, needing some paint to also be presentable, but not your ride of choice.


If you can, keep and use the Valiant as is. Purchase your project, and start acquiring parts and getting things done. Your project will probably not be really ready for a couple of years, and having the Val will tie you over. After Duster is running, if you want to sell the val.. you'll know.

Good luck
Grant
 
I would love to have that car! How much would you like to get for it? What color interior does it have? Would it make a drive to Minnesota? I have a very solid 1973 Fury Wagon, pretty nice shape, interested in a trade? I drove the Wagon home from Washinton to Minnesota with no issues. I know you want a Duster but thought I would ask! The Fury is in the back ground of the picture. Keith.

DSC00749.jpg
 
If you can, keep and use the Valiant as is. Purchase your project, and start acquiring parts and getting things done. Your project will probably not be really ready for a couple of years, and having the Val will tie you over. After Duster is running, if you want to sell the val.. you'll know.

Grant

Unfortunately I don't think I can afford to have a driver project and another long-term one at the same time, but yes that would be an ideal scenario if I could. Selling the Val would help to finance a Duster. Hence the Dilemma.

Never thought about it like that though, maybe I can find a way to move some finances around. :-D
 
I like most A bodies (if not all) and if I had the chance to buy a Valiant, I would... but if the Duster is the car that your soul wants then get a Duster! Do not try to suppress your true feelings with any kind of excuses!
 
For YEARS I wanted a 69 Dart like the one my brother had when I was a kid. I never bought one. I restored a 60 Chevy BelAir instead. Local, cheap car with parts available. I sold that due to boredom, and built a 69 Nova street/strip car. Sold that too. 355/4-speed 12 bolt Cragar's. Cool car, but....
Then I wanted another Vette so I found and bought a good one. Drove it for 9 years while my kids were too young to be hearing wrenching late at night and smelling paint fumes. I started looking for a Dart Swinger 340 before the Vette was even sold, and had mine all lined up so as soon as the Vette was gone, I picked up the Dart the following day.
I don't regret a thing. I'm sure I'll own another Corvette; it's in my blood, but I'm having a blast with this car, and I haven't even driven it yet. I've been driving Mopar 4X4 trucks since 1986 so I've been Mopar for a long time too.
What I'm saying is this; if you're READY to move on, you'll not have any regrets. If the time isn't right, you'll hem& haw about it. Thats how you can tell whether or not to pull the trigger.

Think about it a little longer. Summer isn't even here yet so you have time to think it over. If it's time to sell, you'll know.

Good Luck!

George
 
Great stuff George, thanks for the thoughtful reply. I know what you mean about the time being right. That's definitely what I was going through when I sold my Belvedere. After almost 10 years of it being incomplete, I couldn't even look it at anymore. It felt like a millstone around my neck - it was definitely time to move on. I don't regret selling it at all and I was actually relieved to see it go down the road.

What might be holding me back a little is the fact that my wife and I had such a good time with it at first, she gives me that hang dog look when I talk about selling it. She's OK with whatever I do though so if and when I do sell she'll be fine with it.
 
If you want a Duster, get a Duster. Be sure though, before you sell the Valiant.

Afraid of losing those memories? You'll still have them, and you'll make new memories with a nice Duster! Personally I prefer early A's even with their problems. I think they're better built, but that's just my bias.

Life is short, gas prices are soaring....one day we might have to convert our cars to electric or something....so get out there and enjoy the car you want! Don't settle.

You'll make someone very happy by selling them that little Valiant, complete with a nice history of the little old lady and they can carry the torch until the next owner. Make sure all the paperwork and history goes with the car, that's your Mopar duty!
 
There's nothing wrong with having a car a few years, enjoying it and then letting someone else have some fun with it too.
The early Valiants are not esay to sell so it might take some time for that but that also gives you time to shop for the car you want.
 
Every one needs a ride !! I like yours :thumbrig:
And if you own the title and have no payments :cheers:
and know your way around the car it could be cheeper to keep the car and drive it as needed.
Like you said you can still get a duster. :-k

I have enjoyed a few and sold afew,
So find your duster then sell it to some one ells
to enjoy if you have too.:dontknow:

Do you have any plans on a family.
I wish I could have kept a couple for my boy's:toothy10:

LIFE 029.jpg


LIFE 030.jpg
 
Do you have any plans on a family.
I wish I could have kept a couple for my boy's:toothy10:

My son was born in March. Can't wait to teach him how to wrench on stuff. Hope he has a taste for shiny mechanical things like his dad! If I can help it, there will never be a shortage of Mopar muscle in the garage.

I can see it now - building blocks, Lego, bicycle, junior dragsters then... Pro Stock!
 
-
Back
Top Bottom