FrostyMopar
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2010
- Messages
- 786
- Reaction score
- 218
I'm just going to ignore the one beating his chest.
Picking the appropriate duration and lobe separation is how you get valve events. (with a certain amount of advance, but that doesn't have to be ground in)
Let me try to put it in a more simplistic way
A cam manufacturer will want every detail you have available for your engine/application.
Bore, Stroke, Rod length, Compression ratio, Cylinder head flow CFM, Valve sizes, converter flash or stall RPM, transmission, differential gears, tire diameter etc etc
They will want to know what the vehicle/engine is going to be used for. Street, Performance street, Street/strip, Circle track, Drag race, Mud racing etc etc.
When all these factors are known, they will already have an idea in their head of roughly what kind of camshaft you need. They will refer to their experience with relatively similar combinations to yours which were successful.
Firstly, a camshaft has lobes.
Lobes are listed in a cam manufacturer's master catalog.
The lobes operate the valves.
"Duration" of a lobe is how long in crank degrees the valve is moved by the camshaft.
"lift" is how far the valve is moved at the lobe's highest point.
Duration has a 100% predictable effect, more duration means it moves the power into the higher RPM range.
200 degrees is a lower rpm lobe which won't make as much power at high rpm.
260 degrees is a higher rpm lobe which won't make as much power at low rpm.
Lift is mostly a function of a cylinder head's capacity to flow air. The higher the lift the better the performance, however you can only get so much lift with a given duration because of physical limitations. Especially with a flat tappet camshaft.
The relative lift to duration is what is known as "Ramp rate". Higher ramp rating is great for performance, but can make an engine become noisy. ramp rating is limited by reliability factors.
Lobes will be listed in a catalogue in a series, first categorized by type.
Hydraulic flat tappet.
Solid flat tappet.
Hydraulic roller.
Solid roller.
Each type will have a few variations.
Some lobes are high ramp rating. (racing only)
Some are low ramp rating (factory replacement)
Some are designed specifically for exhaust only.
Some are designed for classes with a maximum lift rule in racing. these are like normal racing lobes with all parts of the lobe which exceeds a specified lift value machined off.
Some are designed with low ratio rocker arms
Some are designed with high ratio rocker arms
Some are designed for valvetrain stability at 10,000 RPM.
Some are designed for towing.
Picking the correct lobes is SUPER IMPORTANT.
If you have basic comphrehension skills, you should pretty obviously see why Picking lobes is the correct place to begin when a professional designs a custom camshaft for a customer.
However when selecting the lobes, you need to take into consideration where the Intake lobes are going to be placed in relation to the exhaust, because this effects the cam's performance dramatically.
The way we select the location of the lobes, is with "lobe separation angle"
Lobe separation angle also has a 100% predictable effect, just like duration. I've already been through them in this thread. but here they are again anyhow.
Now every motor is different. So the correct cam for a 225ci slant six won't be the same for a 440.
The cam manufacturers have experience and first hand knowledge in what works with particular applications. But for example a 350 chev, 351 ford, and 360 mopar with the same compression ratio and cylinder head flow are going to need similar cams if they have a common purpose/rpm range.
This experience and knowledge is less about being an award winning mathematician and more about experience which makes them aware of What lobes to select and where to put them.
Even a very good professional cam guru will probably look at a bunch of valve event timing figures and then instantly perform the maths to convert it to Duration and Lobe separation to figure out what the heck the cam is actually good for.
Measurements like Valve timing events are something which occurs as a result of picking everything else. Much like overlap
You wouldn't go to a cam manufacturer and say "I want a camshaft with 22 degrees valve overlap".
I'm sure they would be polite if you did, but it's not helpful in determining the correct camshaft.
Valve timing events are similar, but to a lesser degree.
Regardless. The best advice you can get WILL ALWAYS come from a tech at a cam manufacturer, not an internet forum.
Picking the appropriate duration and lobe separation is how you get valve events. (with a certain amount of advance, but that doesn't have to be ground in)
Let me try to put it in a more simplistic way
A cam manufacturer will want every detail you have available for your engine/application.
Bore, Stroke, Rod length, Compression ratio, Cylinder head flow CFM, Valve sizes, converter flash or stall RPM, transmission, differential gears, tire diameter etc etc
They will want to know what the vehicle/engine is going to be used for. Street, Performance street, Street/strip, Circle track, Drag race, Mud racing etc etc.
When all these factors are known, they will already have an idea in their head of roughly what kind of camshaft you need. They will refer to their experience with relatively similar combinations to yours which were successful.
Firstly, a camshaft has lobes.
Lobes are listed in a cam manufacturer's master catalog.
The lobes operate the valves.
"Duration" of a lobe is how long in crank degrees the valve is moved by the camshaft.
"lift" is how far the valve is moved at the lobe's highest point.
Duration has a 100% predictable effect, more duration means it moves the power into the higher RPM range.
200 degrees is a lower rpm lobe which won't make as much power at high rpm.
260 degrees is a higher rpm lobe which won't make as much power at low rpm.
Lift is mostly a function of a cylinder head's capacity to flow air. The higher the lift the better the performance, however you can only get so much lift with a given duration because of physical limitations. Especially with a flat tappet camshaft.
The relative lift to duration is what is known as "Ramp rate". Higher ramp rating is great for performance, but can make an engine become noisy. ramp rating is limited by reliability factors.
Lobes will be listed in a catalogue in a series, first categorized by type.
Hydraulic flat tappet.
Solid flat tappet.
Hydraulic roller.
Solid roller.
Each type will have a few variations.
Some lobes are high ramp rating. (racing only)
Some are low ramp rating (factory replacement)
Some are designed specifically for exhaust only.
Some are designed for classes with a maximum lift rule in racing. these are like normal racing lobes with all parts of the lobe which exceeds a specified lift value machined off.
Some are designed with low ratio rocker arms
Some are designed with high ratio rocker arms
Some are designed for valvetrain stability at 10,000 RPM.
Some are designed for towing.
Picking the correct lobes is SUPER IMPORTANT.
If you have basic comphrehension skills, you should pretty obviously see why Picking lobes is the correct place to begin when a professional designs a custom camshaft for a customer.
However when selecting the lobes, you need to take into consideration where the Intake lobes are going to be placed in relation to the exhaust, because this effects the cam's performance dramatically.
The way we select the location of the lobes, is with "lobe separation angle"
Lobe separation angle also has a 100% predictable effect, just like duration. I've already been through them in this thread. but here they are again anyhow.
Now every motor is different. So the correct cam for a 225ci slant six won't be the same for a 440.
The cam manufacturers have experience and first hand knowledge in what works with particular applications. But for example a 350 chev, 351 ford, and 360 mopar with the same compression ratio and cylinder head flow are going to need similar cams if they have a common purpose/rpm range.
This experience and knowledge is less about being an award winning mathematician and more about experience which makes them aware of What lobes to select and where to put them.
Even a very good professional cam guru will probably look at a bunch of valve event timing figures and then instantly perform the maths to convert it to Duration and Lobe separation to figure out what the heck the cam is actually good for.
Measurements like Valve timing events are something which occurs as a result of picking everything else. Much like overlap
You wouldn't go to a cam manufacturer and say "I want a camshaft with 22 degrees valve overlap".
I'm sure they would be polite if you did, but it's not helpful in determining the correct camshaft.
Valve timing events are similar, but to a lesser degree.
Regardless. The best advice you can get WILL ALWAYS come from a tech at a cam manufacturer, not an internet forum.















