student reprimanded for tackling a knife wielding classmate

-

Drache

1971 Dodge Dart Swinger
Joined
May 10, 2011
Messages
1,895
Reaction score
128
Location
Williams Lake, BC, Canada
Grade 7 student Briar MacLean was reprimanded for tackling a knife wielding classmate

There was a time when 13-year-old Briar MacLean would have been hailed as a hero for saving a fellow student.

It takes courage and conviction to tackle someone threatening a classmate with a knife — but instead of a pat on the back, the Grade 7 student at Sir John A. Macdonald school was taught a harsh lesson in minding his own business.

“I received a call from the school’s vice-principal indicating there was an incident at the school and that my son had been involved,” said Leah O’Donnell, Briar’s mom.

“I was informed that my son was in trouble for being a part of it.”

Kids getting in trouble at school is nothing new — but Briar, according to what the vice-principal told his mom, was in the hot seat for preventing a potential tragedy on Tuesday morning.

The trouble started over an altercation between two boys at the school, located at 6600 4 St. N.W.

Again, school scraps are nothing unique — but then one of the boys pulled out a knife, turning an angry scuffle into something far more serious and potentially deadly.

At this point, according to the strict rules of the Calgary Board of Education junior high, MacLean should have left the scene to find a teacher, abandoning the unarmed student to his fate.

But instead of doing what was required, MacLean did what was right.

The young teen charged into the fray and tackled the knife-brandishing student.

The jolt sent the student and knife to the floor, leaving the potential stabber with a nasty bump on his noggin — but that was the extent of injuries received at Sir John A. Macdonald school that day.

No cuts, no stab wounds, and no need to call an ambulance — all thanks to a kid who chose to act rather than cower or run.

“He pulled out his flip knife so I came in and pushed him into the wall,” said MacLean.

“It was just to help the other kid so he wouldn’t get hurt.”

MacLean’s reward was a day in the office, removed from the other students, and a stern lecture about not playing the hero.

Thankfully, the boy has a family to tell him what’s right.

“They told him they don’t condone heroics in the school and he wasn’t allowed to go back to class for the day,” said O’Donnell.

“Isn’t that horrible? We’ve taught him to do the right thing, and to step in — in our family we teach our children that they need to stand up for others and not run from danger out of self-preservation.”

The school itself didn’t return calls Wednesday, and a spokeswoman with the Calgary Board of Education said details of the incident couldn’t be discussed due to privacy regulations.

But the Calgary Police Service confirmed they were called to Sir John A. Macdonald school that morning, where a student had pulled a knife while fighting with another, and a third boy had intervened to disarm the student.

The student with the knife has apparently been suspended and police are still investigating, meaning charges have not been ruled out.

In the meantime, MacLean has been left to believe he’s done something wrong — though thankfully, he says he’d do it all over again.

His mom, meanwhile, is fighting back, exposing the school’s attitude on the matter and saying students shouldn’t be taught that sticking up for others is wrong.

“When did we decide as a society to allow our children to grow up without spines? Without a decent sense of the difference between right and wrong?” reads the letter she wrote to the Sun.

Obviously, no school will encourage kids to place themselves in harm’s way — but to condemn a student who likely saved another from serious injury or even death is a terrible lesson for the entire junior high.

“We’re coddling kids and that doesn’t make for strong individuals when they grow up,” said O’Donnell.

“What are we teaching these children?”

http://www.calgarysun.com/2013/05/3...ding-classmate-at-sir-john-a-macdonald-school
 
That's unbeleiveable bs. At least HE understands he did the right thing and hopefully the way he thinks won't change.
 
independent thinking isnt welcomed in schools today , hats off to him for making a judgement call . It's nice to here that he didnt get hurt in the process nor the other kid . Now let em' beat the snot out of each other shake ands and hit the playground . They complained at the church nursery that my son retaliated after being pushed by the pastors kid(wife saw it happen) . I said that i was pleased that he did not allow himself to be the victim....they had no comment
 
It's no wonder assailants can easily go into our schools and mow children down. We're being taught one generation at a time to lay down and be well......you know.........
 
He was stupid, but may have learned a valuable lesson: Never help, never stop, never get involved, it is never worth the risk. Walk away, hands in pockets, head down and pick up the pace. No good deed goes unpunished.
 
All I can say is wow what are they grooming are kids for. To just give up when they decide to take over.
 
It is a shame as to what we have become, cower in fear, don't get involved etc.

Walmart fired three employees a year or so ago for stopping a man with a gun from committing an act of violence against someone in the store, FLAT OUT fired them.
 
I can see this one getting out of hand real fast.

It is the liberal mindset. Do not under any circumstances show any kind of backbone, unless it is to push the liberal agenda. What this kid did is a direct assault on the liberal way. It is what is taught in conservative circles. Be an upstanding citizen at any age and you will be shunned by the left which is what our education system is run by.

Jack
 
I got into the same type deal, only a lot less violent, in high school. We had one out and out bully. Now I was never much of a fighter, but you can push me "so far." I was talking to a kid I knew, and the bully came up behind, knocked his books out to get him to turn around and then slammed the kid's locker door into him.

I saw him coming, knew his history, and "something happened." So I belted him one

We had a "jock run letterman/ kangeroo student court" and they wanted me to come out Saturday and pickup trash.

I bet some of those guys --still alive-- STILL remember that conversation

I had had enough. Told them in so many words to "f off" you guys know this kid is a bully and he has.......etc.

I guess they had no actual authority, as I got into no further trouble.

So, "this ****" started way back then. This was 1965

By the way, the bully got killed. We used to have a REAL wind-ey two lane highway, he passed a car on a windy curve and got hit head on. Car 1, bike zero. Seriously dead.
 
It is a shame as to what we have become, cower in fear, don't get involved etc.

Walmart fired three employees a year or so ago for stopping a man with a gun from committing an act of violence against someone in the store, FLAT OUT fired them.

It's not fear. I am not AFRAID to help. I have DECIDED that I am UNWILLING to help. I did a cost-benefit analysis and concluded that the potential cost is high and the potential benefit is zero. My give-a-damn is busted and has been for a long time.
 
It's not fear. I am not AFRAID to help. I have DECIDED that I am UNWILLING to help. I did a cost-benefit analysis and concluded that the potential cost is high and the potential benefit is zero. My give-a-damn is busted and has been for a long time.
Really glad you are NOT my neighbor !!!
 
Somethings are worth risking life for. There are those who will just never get that.
 
It's not fear. I am not AFRAID to help. I have DECIDED that I am UNWILLING to help. I did a cost-benefit analysis and concluded that the potential cost is high and the potential benefit is zero. My give-a-damn is busted and has been for a long time.

What a great attitude. Your friends call you "Geoawge CosTANzia?"

Really glad you are NOT my neighbor !!!

X10


X10

Somethings are worth risking life for. There are those who will just never get that.

Yup.

Think about this, Jar. Someday YOU may need help. Might not be a violent crime, might be a car crash you are in, a house fire, most anything. "People just like you" just keep walkin' by like they don't even see ya.
 
What is this world coming to???...The "hero" student is being reprimanded for doing the right thing. Soon, everyone will just turn their backs on things happening around them because they are "afraid" of the consequences (sp) of "getting involved". WHAT A CROCK OF BULL MUFFINS. JMO.
 
He was stupid, but may have learned a valuable lesson: Never help, never stop, never get involved, it is never worth the risk. Walk away, hands in pockets, head down and pick up the pace. No good deed goes unpunished.

So what if it was your kid in that situation where someone pulled a knife on him, and there was someone nearby who could help, but didn't? Would you be glad the other kid had gone off, without helping, while your kid was left to try to get away from somebody holding a knife on him?

I salute this young man who had the courage to actually think of someone other than himself (very rare, these days) and prevented a tragedy from happening. This kid should be rewarded, not punished. I'm glad to hear that he would do it again, regardless!
 
I guess I have to ask the question: would you lay down your life for your wife or kids? I know I would!
 
I can see this one getting out of hand real fast.

It is the liberal mindset. Do not under any circumstances show any kind of backbone, unless it is to push the liberal agenda. What this kid did is a direct assault on the liberal way. It is what is taught in conservative circles. Be an upstanding citizen at any age and you will be shunned by the left which is what our education system is run by.

Jack

This bears repeating, and a little more emphasis!

It is the liberal mindset. Do not under any circumstances show any kind of backbone, unless it is to push the liberal agenda. What this kid did is a direct assault on the liberal way. It is what is taught in conservative circles. Be an upstanding citizen at any age and you will be shunned by the left which is what our education system is run by.

Jack
 
What is this world coming to???...The "hero" student is being reprimanded for doing the right thing. Soon, everyone will just turn their backs on things happening around them because they are "afraid" of the consequences (sp) of "getting involved". WHAT A CROCK OF BULL MUFFINS. JMO.
I don't think so- I bet that kid would still do the right thing even if he knew he'd get in trouble for it (and he'll get enough positive reinforcement for this that he'll know he did the right thing even if the school's 'official policy' disagrees).
 
My eldest is25 he was always bullied and the school board would do nothing .when he did fight back he was suspended . His mother and I always told him and his never throw the first punch always throw the last . And never step into a fair fight but always step in when it becomes unfair even if your friends are wrong you fight for what you believe and always have your friends back no matter what .school was rough for him but he just graduated forms queens university in Kingston ontario.his younger brother won't back down from anything and is going thru to be law inforcement .Even with all the bullying he found the right path and is heading into social work . We're proud of both .We had to realize that we had to I instill the values in them and they were not to expect other parents to do the same with there kids .
 
Perhaps you are being too hard on Jarlaxle by taking him literally. I don't believe he's the type of person who would leave someone to a tragic fate if he was in a position to do something about it. What I think he is saying is that by allowing the forces that advocate and preach such nonsense to remain in control, WE are becoming responsible for the societal cowardice and moral rot that now plagues most of "civilized" humanity. He is simply emphasizing the frustration we face when trying to fix the problem.
 
-
Back
Top