Opinions on 4 speed with OD

-

Steve welder

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2021
Messages
1,806
Reaction score
2,519
Location
New York
I have a 833 4 speed with 355 gears in my car, im not comfortable driving on the highway
It revs to high for my taste. My options seem to be a 5 speed Tremec, a 833 with the 4th gear OD from Dan Brewer, Passions Hemi 4 speed with OD or a Gear Venders OD unit
The trans from Brewers is the least expensive way to go plus I know if Dan did the trans its done right
The 5 speed is a little more than id want to spend
The thought of driving the car now 100 miles down I95 does not appeal to me, at 50 the tach was showing close to 2500. Its a small column mounted tac and I use reading glasses but thats about what I could see
Any and all thoughts are welcomed
 
Well, it's well known that the Factory OD unit, with the large retainer and aluminum case, Cannot take abuse at all from some horses. That said I've had a few of them in trucks behind slant sixes and they're a damn good unit for just cruising around in a truck. I had a step side, I'd rev that slant up, side step the clutch, She'd just boil the back tires. I don't know if Brewer did anything to address that or not...
 
I have a 833 4 speed with 355 gears in my car, im not comfortable driving on the highway
It revs to high for my taste. My options seem to be a 5 speed Tremec, a 833 with the 4th gear OD from Dan Brewer, Passions Hemi 4 speed with OD or a Gear Venders OD unit
The trans from Brewers is the least expensive way to go plus I know if Dan did the trans its done right
The 5 speed is a little more than id want to spend
The thought of driving the car now 100 miles down I95 does not appeal to me, at 50 the tach was showing close to 2500. Its a small column mounted tac and I use reading glasses but thats about what I could see
Any and all thoughts are welcomed

Those boxes are 4 speeds that replace 3rd gear with an over driven gear set. Then the 3-4 lever is flipped upside down so that when you push the lever and and get the handle in 3rd gear (on the H pattern) you are really putting the transmission into 4th gear, which is direct. When you pull the lever into 4th (on the H pattern) you are really putting the transmission back into 3rd gear which has been overdriven.

Those boxes will take more abuse than people think.
 
I'm just at this dilemma myself. I was considering an OD A833, but putting all the internals into an iron case to take care of the sloppy shaft issues associated with the aluminum cases. A buddy of mine runs one in his 73 Duster 340, his take on it is it is only good on the highway, says the RPM drop between 1st and 2nd is nasty. This has caused me to rethink the swap. I agree, swapping center sections is the quickest and easiest. It may not however be the most economical method, to have 3 chunks built to suit driving moods?

Does Passon still produce the gearset as a kit for a you build project? I was recently on his site, I only see complete Hemi OD transmissions available, not gearset. Does anyone with experience with these want to chime in on driveability, and rpm drop between gears?
 
Those boxes are 4 speeds that replace 3rd gear with an over driven gear set. Then the 3-4 lever is flipped upside down so that when you push the lever and and get the handle in 3rd gear (on the H pattern) you are really putting the transmission into 4th gear, which is direct. When you pull the lever into 4th (on the H pattern) you are really putting the transmission back into 3rd gear which has been overdriven.

Those boxes will take more abuse than people think.
Yes they will, especially the factory cast iron cases or the aluminum case that's had the counter shaft bushed. But you knew all that already.
 
I run an OD box, might even be aluminum (can’t remember for sure right now). The rpm drop isn’t great but I don’t remember ever saying I can’t stand it. Could be better, but I like my 3.21’s and OD on the highway running 2000 rpm at 65 mph.

Biggest issue I have is the large rpm drop has done a real number on the synchro’s. It’s not undriveable yet, but I have to be pretty gentle on a high rpm shift to avoid grinding gears.

I’m actually planning a 6 speed swap in the next 18 months or so. Who knows if it will happen, but it’s the plan. Unless I buy another 6M Challenger, then who knows.
 
I was just going by something I read 25 or 30 years ago.... I'll blame it on Rick E...
He's right actually.....that is IF you do not bush the aluminum case 4 speed. Once you do, they will take almost all the abuse as a standard 4 speed. The cast iron case models are pretty much on par with the standard 4 speed.
 
Any and all thoughts are welcomed
Whoa hold your horses boys, lol.
2500@50mph points to 3.91s
The following are my opinions based on 4 years of trying to be happy with it.
1) 2500 is nearly ideal for fuel economy. Any slower and with the factory type distributor, you cannot give the engine the cruise-timing it wants, to get optimum fuel-economy.
But I gotta agree, 100 miles at 50 mph pretty much sucks.
2) I can tell you that, in the the NON-od gears it easily puts up with 430 hp, and even in the factory Alloy box, altho I fixed the anti-rattle front pin-hole.
3) Another thing that I can tell you, is that any high-winding engine will NOT like the wide gear ratios, at lower rpms. You are gonna need plenty of cylinder pressure to be satisfied.
4) the ratios are; 3.09-1.67-1.00-.73od
the splits are .54-.60-.73
That means that whatever you rev it to, on the shifts the rpm will drop to these percents.
If you are used to the ~.72 splits of the Standard A833, and have a torquey SBM, then you re probably used to shifting at ~2800 around town. If yes then the Rs will fall to .72 x 2800= ~2000. So your engine needs a good amount of torque, to make that doable in each successive gear.
But with the od box, shifting at 2800, the Rs drop to; 1500/1700/and 2050, but you gotta baby it into od, lest that gear shatters. I broke a couple of them before I smartened up. So if your engine has no balls at 1500 to 1700, you are gonna have to rev it higher before shifting. For instance, to come in at the same 2000 as with the Standard box, you would have to rev it to 3700 on the 1-2, and to 3330 on the 2-3 shift.
With 3.91s your roadspeeds are 24mph at 3700 in first and 41 at 3330 in second. 65mph is ~2300
For me, that trans sucked.
At that time, I had an 11.3Scr alloy-headed 367 making about 185psi, with a [email protected] cam, and was trying desperately to run 3.55s, for 65=2100.

If you are worried about the overdrive box, Passon sold me one of his boxes and side covers, which I have not been able to break

My Opinion is to swap the 3.91s to 3.23s, and get a Commando gearset. It has ratios of 3.09-1.92-1.40-1.00, and splits of .62-.73-.72 super nice.
If you currently have a Standard box with ratios of 2.66-1.92-1.40-1.00 you are already familiar with these splits. And your starter gear is 2.66 x 3.91=10.40 which is quite nice.
To get the same starter with the Commando, you could use 10.40/3.09=3.37s which could be rounded down to 3.23s or up to 3.55s.

3.23s will get you about 65=2600, with a starter gear of 9.98 which is a hardly noticeable difference from 10.40.
At 2600, you can almost give an SBM the cruise-timing it wants, which could be as high as 56*. You can modify the Vcan for 24*, and run an initial of 14* and another 14 centrifugal; for a total of 52*, that's dang close.

I love my Commando box. I got the gearset from Passon. They come up for sale here from time to time.
I wanna say that I would not run this box with a 3.31 stroke engine, but behind my winter engine, a low-compression 318 it wasn't all that bad, lol. But I wasn't looking for performance...... either.
 
Last edited:
Taller tires or higher gears. I would never do the over drive. I drove one and that was enough for me. Remember. OD is 1st,2nd to 1- 1 dirrect , and then OD. an 833 is 1st ,2nd,3rd, 1-1 direct. . Get 323's and a taller tire you'll be a happy camper.
 
Taller tires or higher gears. I would never do the over drive. I drove one and that was enough for me. Remember. OD is 1st,2nd to 1- 1 dirrect , and then OD. an 833 is 1st ,2nd,3rd, 1-1 direct. . Get 323's and a taller tire you'll be a happy camper.
 
@AJ/FormS says
Whoa hold your horses boys, lol.
2500@50mph points to 3.91s

At what tire size?
How many combinations can you come up with that has the engine at 2500 rpm at xx speed.

Ahhhhhh, come on now!
Assume much? OK just a little….
 
Personally I think the gear vendors is an expensive waste. I’d go for the Tremac in the flavor you like.
I owned and driven a Duster with the big drop in the 1-2 gear shift. It was weird at first but I got used to it quickly .
I would say you need a few more rpm’s for a good shift into 2nd and be an effective gear change without chugging the set up. It really is t a huge massive PIA drop deal making the car a PIA to drive. A minor caveat.

AJ always makes the calculation and normally will point out the final drive ratio WHICH SHOULD BE COMBINED W/the TIRE SIZE, to calculate the final drive rpm at a given speed.

Just do the math, gear ratio X the trans ratio = final drive ratio. Coupled to tire size.

I have a 833 4 speed with 355 gears in my car, im not comfortable driving on the highway
It revs to high for my taste. My options seem to be a 5 speed Tremec, a 833 with the 4th gear OD from Dan Brewer, Passions Hemi 4 speed with OD or a Gear Venders OD unit
The trans from Brewers is the least expensive way to go plus I know if Dan did the trans its done right
The 5 speed is a little more than id want to spend
The thought of driving the car now 100 miles down I95 does not appeal to me, at 50 the tach was showing close to 2500. Its a small column mounted tac and I use reading glasses but thats about what I could see
Any and all thoughts are welcomed
 
He's right actually.....that is IF you do not bush the aluminum case 4 speed. Once you do, they will take almost all the abuse as a standard 4 speed. The cast iron case models are pretty much on par with the standard 4 speed.
Cool Man! It's been so long, I caint remember where I read that. Maybe the Chassis book? I dunno, many cells ago
 
I run an 833 O/D in the 66 Barracuda with a 273. No problems here. I swapped the O/D gears and tail housing into an early cast iron housing. Then all you have to do is swap the 3-4 lever and rod. No other changes. It just slips into the place your old 833 resided. You can always go back. As far as 2,500 rpm for a small block MOPAR, that is not too high. It should do that all day long. My 273 is never shifted below 3,000 rpm anyway. We always thought 3.23 gears were the best all around gears for an A Body.
 
We did this car back in 2007 for the Hot Rod Power Tour as Long Hauler.
451 stroker,3.73 rear,Passon 4 speed OD.Car averaged 20 mpg.Bare bones, no A/C,no power nothing.
Cruised 65-75 in comfort. It's what the owner wanted. The stock Slant Six Dart next to it went along too and it's average was 20 mpg as a comparison. Just another opinion.
100_1169.JPG
 
Last edited:
I answered your other post. I had 2 cars with the Tremec and one with the Passion 4 speed OD.
I would do the 4 speed OD again over the 5 speed.Just my 2 cents.
 
Last edited:
I answered your other post. I had 2 cars with the Tremic and one with the passion 4 speed OD.
I would do the 4 speed OD again over the 5 speed.Just my 2 cents.
Im going to call Passion of not today very soon. My current 833 was done over so its in good shape, I will ask him if he wants it on a partial trade
I know the guy has a good reputation and I have talked to him in the past
The deciding factor is I can drive to his shop. All shipping costs would be eliminated and that brings my cost down
I will post later on what he tells me
I want to thank everyone for the replies
 
Im going to call Passion of not today very soon. My current 833 was done over so its in good shape, I will ask him if he wants it on a partial trade
I know the guy has a good reputation and I have talked to him in the past
The deciding factor is I can drive to his shop. All shipping costs would be eliminated and that brings my cost down
I will post later on what he tells me
I want to thank everyone for the replies
And be aware this requires a clutch change also due to being 18 spline, vs 23. This will add to the expense up front. I look forward to learning if he still sells the conversion gear sets.
 
And be aware this requires a clutch change also due to being 18 spline, vs 23. This will add to the expense up front. I look forward to learning if he still sells the conversion gear sets.

Good call. Mine was a brand new install. He did as of last November.
 
-
Back
Top